| Estelle Higgons | 1944-45 | Harry Weible | Dorothea Weisent | 1982 | James Barnett | |
| Elsie McCool |
1946 |
Harry Wheeler | Jane Bayley | 1983 | Steve DeNayer | |
| Dulcie Watkins |
1947 |
J. Ray Ward | Lucille Downerd | 1984 | Johnnie Jones | |
| Evelyn Ward |
1948 |
Ebbert Hall | Helen Ittner | 1985 | William Ittner | |
| Lucille Smith |
1949 |
Ernest Mitchell | Carolyn Nichols | 1986 | Rodney Nichols | |
| Carrol Kettering | 1950 | Lester Kettering | Kathie Wakefield | 1987 | Lynn Gilmore | |
| Marian Judisch | 1951 | Albert Watkins | Kathleen George | 1988 | Clyde George | |
| Flossie DeHoff | 1952 | Phillip Stahlheber | Patricia Slatzer | 1989 | Allen Slatzer | |
| Mary J. Eankin | 1953 | James McSwegin | Barbara Turner | 1990 | Frank Turner | |
| Olga Reitz | 1954 | Louis Sell | Mary Gilmore | 1991 | Lynn Gilmore | |
| Glenna Stahlheber | 1955 | Clinton Johnson | Ruth Wilkes | 1992 | Walter Wilkes | |
| Elizabeth Wallace | 1956 | Thomas Dalzell | Carol Jones | 1993 | Johnnie Jones | |
| Ethel Young | 1957 | Milton Leuthold | Constance Gay | 1994 | Scott Gay | |
| Eleanor Green | 1958 | Merle Shepherd | Sandra Stahler | 1995 | H. Wm. Stahler | |
| Margaret Baltzell | 1959 | Wilson Noel | Carol Jones | 1996 | Johnnie Jones | |
| Kathryn Stimmel | 1960 | Vincent Stimmel | Suzanne Williams | 1997 | James Williams | |
| Sara Sue Bartolet | 1961 | George Bates | Donna Hamer | 1998 | Johnnie Jones | |
| Anne Moore | 1962 | Emmett Wallace | Sandra Norman | 1999 | Skip Norman | |
| Frances Barkman | 1963 | Clyde Holder | Barbara Turner | 2000 | Skip Norman | |
| Ula McArthur | 1964 | Lawrence McArthur | Dolores Kobzowicz | 2001 | Thomas Lilly | |
| Edna Creager | 1965 | Wayne McElhenie | Donna Hamer | 2002 | Skip Norman | |
| Evelyn Guist | 1966 | George Moore | Carol Jones (CJ) | 2003 | Johnnie Jones | |
| Jane Martin | 1967 | Delbert Poland | Dolores Kobzowicz | 2004 | Fred Vogt | |
| Erma G. Karrer | 1968 | Chester Hopton | Lori Givler | 2005 | Trevor Sproul | |
| Doris Bates | 1969 | George MacPherson | Paula J. Brown | 2006 | Fred McGavern | |
| Jane Bayley | 1970 | Dale Griffey | Delores Kobzowicz | 2007 | Johnnie W. Jones | |
| Doris Frenz | 1971 | John Frenz | ||||
| Inez Miller | 1972 | Dale Burlingame | ||||
| Minnie Snyder | 1973 | Marlin Snyder | ||||
| Irene Eiler | 1974 | Rolland Eiler | ||||
| Ruth Glenn | 1975 | Victor Glenn | ||||
| Pauline Ford | 1976 | Ralph Lynn | ||||
| Carol Wisor | 1977 | Lou Rice | ||||
| Clara Stalcup | 1978 | Emory Hall | ||||
| Ruth Wilkes | 1979 | Walter Wilkes | ||||
| Darleen Loy | 1980 | Frank Denayer | ||||
| Carol Jones | 1981 | Johnnie Jones |